There’s Pure Silver in This Mess

Mets GM Sandy Alderson

As the Sterling Boys continue to consider the available options to extricate themselves from the Madoff mess……that screaming $1.0 billion dollar lawsuit slapped on them by Madoff Trustee Irving Picard for essentially looking the other way at the steady 16%-18% annual returns his ponzi scheme threw off….several options have been discussed, most centered around selling parts of the enterprise.

Clearly, the plans have been fluid. 

In December, after the lawsuit was filed, we heard Daddy’s Boy, Mets COO Jeffie Wilpon,  tell us that “no part of the team is for sale. Period. We have many options available, like tapping the banking system for money, etc.”

One week later the real COO of the club, Daddy Fred, gave young Jeffie a public slap by calling a news conference to announce their credit line was essentially tapped out, at both the banks and MLB, and they would sell up to 25% of the club, maintaining all control. No other part of the enterprise, meaning cash positive regional sports channel SNY among others, would be included in the deal.  

Two weeks later, we heard “OK, we might sell up to 49% of the club while maintaining total control of the club. Oh, and maybe we will include a portion of SNY in the sale.”

So the revenue raise has been somewhat of a moving target, which is natural I guess as discussions with potential buyers begin.  WFAN show host Mike Francesa, who seems as wired as anyone on this freak show,  reported that as many as 30 different groups had contacted Allen & Co’s Steve Greenberg to express interest in the deal.  Francesa further stated that the Mets hoped to conclude the sale by June or July and interpreted that they had enough cash on hand to run the club up until that point.

In today’s New York Post, columnist Joel Sherman, proposes a silver lining to this black cloud and it was something I had not considered.  Essentially, Sherman suggests that the Mets do a complete salary/player dump and enter 2012 with a greatly reduced payroll (complete story linked below) and rebuilding type team.  

I know that Mets GM Sandy Alderson is up to the task and I say let him at it. 

Sherman reminds us that this season, the Mets payroll is in the $140 million range with expiring contracts ahead for starters Carlos Beltran ($19.4) and Jose Reyes ($9.375) as well as those two constant thorns in Mets fans sides, Oliver Perez  ($12.0) and Luis Castillo ($6.25).  The club also has an option on K-Rod that would cost them $3.5 million but with a salary this year of $11.5 million, that means a net savings of $8.0 million.  Add the 5 salaries together and you come to a total of $55.0 million dollars….not too shabby.

You can’t see the team just releasing these players out right.   Beltran, Reyes and K-Rod all have value in trades and GM Alderson would have little trouble making deals that returns young and inexpensive talent.   Executing that strategy essentially relegates the Mets to second or even third tier status in their own division, considering the strength of the Phillies, re-emergence of the Braves and budding youth and optimism among Nationals fans. 

That’s where Sherman pushes on, essentially saying, “why stop there”?  His idea is to also move Jason Bay and his $8.6 million, Johan Santana ($20.4) and even David Wright ($10.25), turning up another $39.3 million.  

Combined with the prior Gang of 5, this roster action creates a savings of $94.3 million! ith contracts to the new players acquired through trades and the remaining Mets, Sherman is estimating a payroll of around $70 million for 2012.

Sherman spoke with 2 different GMs who estimated that the Mets could sell about 2 million tickets with a rebuilding roster…and that combined with salary savings, could allow the club to actually earn a profit.  I don’t have enough insight to agree or disagree with any certainty, but that ticket sales figure seems high to me considering the cost of seats at CitiField.  And this strategy doesn’t really solve the need to raise instant cash to handle the Madoff mess.

But Sherman suggests that the club could potentially calm their bankers nerves and might even open the spigot again for additional loans should the hoped for profits materialize. 

Sherman argues that the strategy is the only course of action. Several “baseball people” suggest that smart fans will get it. The Mets today, as built, are not capable of winning a championship, even if the moon and stars align.  They need a re-haul and why not start today, in full? 

Sherman believes that the Wilpons have been deluding themselves for years that they are “one player away” from a title and have never shown the “discipline or intellect” to stick with a rebuilding plan in the past.    And that’s where Alderson’s experience and credibility comes in….convincing the Wilpons that this is the ONLY course of action.

I think he is already examining this entire strategy….remember, Alderson hired two expensive old hands as Assistant GMs…Paul DePodesta who worked with Alderson in Oakland and went on to lead the Dodgers (only to get fired immediately by the train wreck Frank McCourt) and JP Riccardi, who led the Blue Jays for years and was with  Boston for one season.  One task for each is to scan the market for younger players with potential and I think they are both accomplished stars at that task. So does Alderson.

I think Sherman is on to something. You?

Related Articles


I am looking forward to the Big East tournament that begins this week… Come on Lavin, get those Johnnies rollin! Can you imagine the hype of St. John’s v. Seton Hall?


About balleehoo

Happily married to Patty and helping to raise two kids...Kat (23) and Kevin (21). Who is luckier than me?
This entry was posted in Baseball, NY Mets, Wilpon/Katz and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to There’s Pure Silver in This Mess

  1. tophatal says:

    There’s not enough brains inside the Mets’ front office to extricate them from this mess !

    tophatal ……………..

  2. balleehoo says:

    I think Sandy Alderson is the real deal….if this is the direction they end up taking, he will execute it very very well.

    • tophatal says:


      Alderson and Ricciardi though experienced with the Mets’ shortcomings on all sides of the ball there isn’t much that they can offer up or do . Who wants a beaten up and worn out ….. Beltran much less K Rod ?

      David Wright is merely a cheap imitation of Jeter who’s yet learned how to lead by example !

      Don’t buy into all of the hype concerning this team because they’ve done nothing in ages other than gotten a moron like Bloomberg to build ’em a big ass stadium that they’re struggling to fill even on a good day !

      tophatal …………………….

  3. Don Daniels says:

    I think that the Sherman scenario is moronic. A massive salary dump in a major market would/should never be tolerated by MLB. If the Picard claim against the Wilpons has merit, then it would seem to me that there must be some MLB convention that could strip the Wilpons of ownership rights. I don’t know the inside details but can’t imagine that there aren’t standards similar to player morality clauses that apply to inappropriate owner activity. The Wilpons may be underwater but the franchise has major value and MLB should step in and protect the integrity of the game and oust this pathetic band of fraudsters.

    • balleehoo says:

      Something tells me that Selig, who has never been impartial, will do whatever he can to save fred wilpon….even if it means staying mum on a rebuild. and that is what i think they will do….and it will be a positive to turn this ship from cash loser to maybe cash positive. I think it tough to sell 2 million tix to a bunch of up and comers, but i bet that’s where this goes.
      interesting story in the LA Times today about how Selig will help Fred, but wants McCourt to go away….and i believe the story is accurate….,0,6737556.story

      • Don Daniels says:

        I’m sure his first impulse will be to try to save the tribe. But the owners and fans will not allow it. If they lose a judgement in excess of $500 million it means they were complicit. They financed a new stadium through a public bond offering built on a mountain of lies. It strikes at the integrity of the game and there will be no cover.

  4. tophatal says:

    Only an idiot at this juncture would touch either the Dodgers or Mets ! And as for Martin Luther King III being interested joining a consortium buying a stake in the team I he ought to stick what he knows best and not get involved in this debacle !

    Selig is acting like a child around a puppy that’s either due to be euthanized when it comes to both of these teams ! He’s remaining quiet for now but he’s scheming to get either someone on the outside to come to the rescue or or he’ll do a David Stern and get some major financial institution to come in and loan the money. I doubt if that’d go down well with the other owners if they’re on the line if either of the two teams were to default in any way !

    tophatal ………………

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s